How to Get a Reservation at Gage & Tollner in New York
Gage & Tollner is the gorgeously restored 1879 chophouse in Downtown Brooklyn. The short answer: it books on Resy on a rolling window, with cancellation watching and weeknight flexibility the realistic ways in.
The short answer
Gage & Tollner books on Resy on a rolling window that opens a set number of days in advance, with prime weekend slots clearing quickly. After the initial drop, same-week cancellations are the realistic path. Verify the current release time on the live Resy listing before you plan a specific night.
Rose watches Gage & Tollner continuously and books the instant a seat opens under your name, so you can land prime time without the manual scramble.
What it is known for and where it sits
On Fulton Street in Downtown Brooklyn, Gage & Tollner is a landmark chophouse that first opened in 1879 and was lavishly restored and reopened in 2021. The gaslit, mirrored room is a stunner, and the menu of oysters, classic seafood, steaks, and old-school showstoppers makes it one of the borough's marquee dining destinations. The upstairs Sunken Harbor Club is a celebrated tiki bar.
Prime weekend dinners are the hardest; weeknights and early seatings open more freely.
- Target weeknights and early or late seatings for the best availability.
- Watch for cancellations in the final 48 hours before your date.
- Smaller parties clear more often than large groups.
Want Gage & Tollner without refreshing Resy? Text Rose and we will watch it for you.
Frequently asked
What platform does Gage & Tollner use for reservations?
Gage & Tollner books on Resy, opening tables on a rolling window a set number of days ahead. Confirm the current release time on its live Resy listing, and watch for cancellations near your date for prime slots.
Is the Sunken Harbor Club bookable separately?
The upstairs Sunken Harbor Club tiki bar operates on its own model and is also popular. Check its current policy directly, as it can differ from the main dining room downstairs.
Can Rose book Gage & Tollner for me?
Yes. Text Rose the date and party size. We watch Gage & Tollner continuously and book the moment a table opens, under your own name, then confirm by text.